
Mark:
I have yet to dive too deep into this game these games yet, but I’ve watched Tyler play it, and I’ve heard the entire world talk about it endlessly for weeks now, so I feel like I can throw a opinions your way.
First off, there is no doubt that the package is a great deal, as there is a lot of great gameplay all crammed on to one disc. It’s also very diverse. It says, “You like FPS’s? Here you go. You like multiplayer shoot ‘em ups? Here you go. You like puzzle games, well, let me just look…yup, got something for you, too.” HOWEVER, saying that it has “five games on one disc” is at the very least a bit misleading. It should be more like, “One game and four half-games,” or even, “One twice-extended game, and two half games.” Also, only three of the games on this disc are originals that we haven’t played before, and only one of those is something completely new. Half-life 2 and Episode One have both been out for a long time already, and Episode 2 is just more of the same. Team Fortress has been around for years on computers, and the Orange Box version has been stripped further than a chop-shop Cadillac. It’s only five maps and three game modes (none of which is Deathmatch). Portal is the only brand new thing that we’ve never seen before, but the fact that you can beat it faster than the 1-2-3 Kid beat Razor Ramon diminishes its value just a little.
So, there is a lot of gameplay this Box that is Orange, but Call of Duty 4, with only a single game (actually two games if you use the OB’s logic) offers much more replay value. But, it is a step in the right direction for companies to give us more virtual bang for our very real buck.
89/100
Russ:
I won’t go into detail about how this is the best bang for your buck on the Xbox 360. I won’t tell you how for $60 you get five awesome games, including three Half-Life 2 games (Half-Life 2, Episode One, and Episode Two, totaling about 25 hours of story-rich gameplay), a mind-bending puzzle game (Portal) and a solid squad-based multiplayer game (Team Fortress 2). And I won’t tell you that its box art is ridiculously dumb.
Instead, I’ll just tell you to spend your hard-earned $60 on this game and never look back. The Half-Life 2 saga is worth the price of admission alone - there is no FPS experience so thought-provoking as this masterpiece. And the achievements are really original and fun (and they have a great progress-tracker, too). Granted, there are too many driving parts, but it’s forgivable. Portal is an interesting few hours, but its re-playability is a little low. Team Fortress 2 hasn’t seen much play on my system, but I will get to it eventually. Even if it ends up sucking, I still got my $60 out of the game.
96/100
Tyler
I don’t even want to write about this game. It’s like reviewing sex. We’ve all heard about it, we all know what it is. Guess what… it’s awesome (from what I hear). I’m pretty hard pressed to find faults in it, but I guess anything can be made better. Here goes…
I hate that The Orange Box didn’t come out two to three months ago when I was so hard pressed for games to play I rented Vampire Reign and Hour of Victory. Seriously though, there are only two things that I can knock TOB for. One is that the source engine is starting to show its age a bit, especially with graphical powerhouses like Gears of War, COD4 and Crysis running around out there. Valve does so much with level design and visual style that I can only imagine what cutting edge graphics added to the already genius presentation would yield. Also, the driving controls are awkward. I wish it was a standard: R Trigger- Gas, L Trigger - Break, L Thumbstick - Steer, X - Exit. Portal is sublime and TF2 is the most excellent online only Team based FPS ever. And there you have it, aside from those two minor slip ups, the box is completely flawless. My game of the year.
99/100
Recent Comments